Tuesday, June 10, 2008

It's Your Money Ralph

Three posts in three days.......It's a blogging frenzy!!!

This latest Commonwealth Bank campaign got me thinking.....how far off the mark are these guys and what really is a relevant insight for a banking customer?

And do you have to employ an american ad agency and feature the bloke who directed Transformers to bring that insight to life?

Maybe the client got sucked into the typical ad agency hype about how an ad has to be funny for it to be effective. I've had this shoved in my face so many times without any insight back to how the target is likely to respond to it in the context of what the brand is trying to say.

So here's the thing. 20 years ago the State Bank of Victoria created an amazing campaign that worked it's way into the vernacular with four words - "It's your money Ralph".

Two actors on a couch, with a newspaper prop, well directed and well written.

It's not funny. It's just true. And it struck a major chord.

Guess which bank owns the State Bank of Victoria now?

14 comments:

Jeffry Pilcher said...

I really don't care for the double-reverse psychology in the Commonwealth campaign. I'm an American, and I can tell you that THAT kind of ad wouldn't work in the U.S.

It's one of those art-imitating-life-imitating-art moments.

Furthermore, the ad's biggest problem is that it draws more attention to itself than it does to the advertiser paying for it. Sure, it gets talked about often, but people aren't talking about the bank. They're talking about the director and the koalas and Mad Max/Crocodile Dundee stereotypes.

It's like the bank is trying to say, "We're going to show you that we understand Australia by showing you the opposite of us." The trouble with this approach is that it can backfire.

In the parody spots, Commonwealth is trying to make the cliché American ad agency look like fools, but in real life, they are the ones that don't look so smart.

Why did they hire an American ad agency in the first place? It a self-indulgent, self-referencing, self-deprecating concept the best the agency could come up with?

I'm curious. What do you think about BankWest's "Happy Banking" campaign? I wrote a review of it here:
http://tinyurl.com/4qfqsh

Jeffry Pilcher
Editor, The Financial Brand
http://www.thefinancialbrand.com

Vando said...

Couldn't agree more jeffry.

Just checked out the Bank West ads. I've seen these on tv and haven't look at them as a marketer, only a disinterested punter. So up until now I thought they were a bit boring and I've never been bothered listening. So by the time it got to the point I'd lost interest. And I thought they looked a bit cheap.

But now that I'm analysing them as a marketer, I quite like them. They're clever, they have a strong point of difference, the campaign has cohesion.

What does that say about our/my ability to subjectively assess ads?!

Also, as pathetic as it sounds, I'm a westpac brand loyalist through and through - it's a good bank that I've been with all my life and don't ever expect to change. So all bank advertising is a bit like car ads - they only become relevant when you need to buy a new car.

Stan Lee said...

My radio had been silent for a while.
A couple of days ago it started to pick up a very faint signal.
That signal is now booming loud, clear and in stereo. Welcome back MMM.
Now if only you could do something about the breakfast show.

Scamp said...

Be funny. Get noticed. Be liked.

That's it.

Advertising isn't a science, and far too many people are paid to pretend it is.

The Commonwealth Bank campaign will work really well, despite the lack of rational consumer benefits, because no one gives a shit about rational consumer benefits except marketers!

People just go with whatever brands they have good feelings about. They almost never research anything, even high ticket items like cars. They haven't got time, and can't be bothered.

They even decide to buy a million dollar house about 30 seconds after walking in. Just a feeling. A whim. We're only human.

Sorry about that!

kuku fashion australia said...

WOW.. Sweet Fashion! Fantastic topics. Liked it., Thanks for the nice Blog. This is really Fantastic. Enjoy online fashion shopping with us! We are- Kuku fashion Australia, with Kuku, Kuku dress, Kuku dresses, Kuku fashion, Mad Love stockist, Mad Love fashion, Toi et Moi online, Toi et Moi jacket, Toi et Moi online. Thanks for staying with us.

Knowledge Plus Australia said...

Thanks for the Great Post. Knowledge Plus is a Registered Training Organisation. training provider australia, certificate iv in business australia, diploma qualifications australia, elearning australia diploma qualifications australia, training provider australia, elearning australia, management qualifications australia, diploma qualifications australia, certificate iv in business australia and many more Training and Supports.

office 365 said...

Thanks for the Great Post. Groupe Conseil Solinteg can support -
office 365
cloud services
sharepoint online
exchange online
lync online
cloud services montreal
microsoft crm montreal
windows intune
and many more services and product from Microsoft Corporation. Thanks.

karmaloop code said...

matryoshka
russian gift
nesting doll
russian dolls
russian hat

green home said...

Thanks for the Great Post. We want a Green earth for LIVE, why we need- green home, green products, green product, buy green, eco friendly products, environmental products, eco green products, environmentally friendly products. Thank you for staying with us.

mou liton said...

We are the contractor since 1980 for alternations, renovations and extensions. On our website you find more information and you can request a quotation. aannemer, aannemersbedrijf, bouwbedrijf, verbouwen, renovatie, kosten uitbouw,kosten verbouwing
Thank for the Post.

oil change va said...

Nice blog. Try to repair engine oil leaks to keep the environment clean. Thanks- oil change and oil change va

stop car engine oil leaks said...

Nice blog. Try to repair car oil leak to keep the environment clean. Thanks- stop car engine oil leaks

how to remove grease said...

Nice blog. Try to know how to remove grease and how to clean oil spills va to keep the environment clean. Thanks- fix engine oil leaks

best wedding coordinator washington state said...

Nice Article topics. This is really excellent and fantastic. I hope it’ll be helpful for our readers. We are - Muse Event Planning and Production, LLC is a full service event planning and production company that can accommodate many types of events. From intimate dinner parties to events/weddings for over three hundred, we can handle every last detail. We work as your seattle wedding planner . We have an extensive list of award winning vendors and venues to build a team for our client’s events that will make any event picture perfect and stress free. We are well known as tacoma wedding planner or tacoma event planner . Our goal is to ensure that our client’s event is a reflection of them and their vision. Using creativity, attention to detail and experience in management and bookkeeping, we vow to create a one-of-a-kind event within their budget. We were rewarded as number one wedding planner seattle last year. We demand, we are the best wedding planner washington state . Thanks for your cooperation.